Black and White Copiers - Advantages and Disadvantages
When choosing a copier for your business, one of the first decisions is whether you need colour capability. Black and white (B&W) copiers remain popular for good reasons, but they’re not right for everyone.
Advantages of B&W copiers
1. Lower cost per page
Significant savings:
| Print type | B&W cost/page | Colour cost/page |
|---|---|---|
| Typical | €0.008-0.015 | €0.04-0.08 |
| Difference | Baseline | 4-8x more |
Annual impact (10,000 pages/month):
- B&W: ~€1,200/year
- Colour: ~€5,000/year
- Savings: €3,800+/year
2. Lower equipment cost
Purchase/rental comparison:
| Equipment | B&W | Colour |
|---|---|---|
| A4 MFP purchase | €1,500-3,000 | €2,500-5,000 |
| A4 MFP rental | €50-90/month | €90-150/month |
| A3 MFP rental | €90-150/month | €150-280/month |
3. Faster printing speeds
B&W often faster:
- No colour processing needed
- Simpler print path
- Single toner application
At same price point:
- B&W machine: 40 ppm
- Colour machine: 30 ppm
4. Lower maintenance needs
Simpler mechanics:
- One toner to manage
- Fewer parts
- Less can go wrong
- Lower service costs
5. More compact options
B&W machines can be:
- Smaller footprint
- Lighter weight
- Easier to place
6. Environmental efficiency
Reduced resources:
- Less consumables
- Less packaging
- Lower energy (often)
- Simpler recycling
Disadvantages of B&W copiers
1. No colour capability
What you can’t do:
- Marketing materials
- Colour presentations
- Charts and graphs (in colour)
- Photos
- Branded documents
2. Less visual impact
Documents lack:
- Colour emphasis
- Visual hierarchy
- Brand colours
- Professional polish (for some purposes)
3. May need second device
If you occasionally need colour:
- Add colour printer
- Use external printing
- Two devices to manage
- Potentially higher total cost
4. Less flexibility
Future needs:
- Can’t “turn on” colour later
- New requirements may force upgrade
- Client expectations may change
5. Market perception
Some contexts:
- B&W may seem outdated
- Clients may expect colour
- Competition may use colour
When B&W makes sense
Ideal use cases
Legal profession:
- Contracts and briefs
- Court documents
- High volume text
- Rarely need colour
Accounting:
- Financial statements
- Invoices
- Reports
- Text-heavy documents
Healthcare:
- Patient records
- Forms and paperwork
- Prescriptions
- Internal documents
Back office:
- Internal memos
- Administrative documents
- Filing copies
- Transaction documents
B&W indicators
Choose B&W if:
- 90%+ of printing is text
- Colour needs can be outsourced
- Cost is primary concern
- High volume, text-focused
When colour is worth it
Colour makes sense for
Marketing-heavy businesses:
- Brochures and flyers
- Proposals
- Presentations
- Client materials
Creative industries:
- Design proofs
- Artwork
- Client presentations
- Visual materials
Client-facing roles:
- External reports
- Proposals
- Branded documents
- Professional presentations
Colour indicators
Choose colour if:
- Regular colour needs
- Client-facing materials
- Brand consistency matters
- Can’t easily outsource colour
The hybrid approach
B&W primary + colour secondary
Configuration:
- High-volume B&W MFP (main device)
- Small colour printer (occasional use)
Advantages:
- Low cost for most printing
- Colour when needed
- Balanced approach
Colour MFP with B&W default
Configuration:
- Colour-capable MFP
- B&W set as default
- Colour requires deliberate selection
Advantages:
- Flexibility
- Cost control
- Single device
This is often the best compromise for modern businesses.
Cost comparison example
Scenario: 5,000 pages/month
Option A: B&W only
- MFP rental: €80/month
- All B&W printing
- No colour capability
Option B: Colour MFP (B&W default)
- MFP rental: €130/month
- 90% B&W, 10% colour
- Full flexibility
Annual comparison:
| Item | B&W only | Colour MFP |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment | €960 | €1,560 |
| Consumables | Included | Included |
| External colour printing | €500+ | €0 |
| Total | €1,460+ | €1,560 |
Conclusion: For €100/year more, full colour capability may make sense.
Decision framework
Ask yourself
- What % of documents need colour?
- Can colour needs be easily outsourced?
- What’s the cost difference?
- Will needs change in contract period?
- What do clients/stakeholders expect?
Quick guide
| Colour need | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| 0-5% | B&W (outsource rare colour) |
| 5-20% | Consider colour with B&W default |
| 20%+ | Definitely colour |
Summary
B&W copiers
Advantages:
- ✅ Lower cost per page (4-8x less)
- ✅ Lower equipment cost
- ✅ Faster speeds at same price
- ✅ Lower maintenance
- ✅ Simpler operation
Disadvantages:
- ❌ No colour capability
- ❌ Less flexible
- ❌ May need second device
- ❌ Can seem outdated
Best approach for most
A colour-capable MFP with B&W as default offers:
- Flexibility when colour needed
- Cost control through defaults
- Single device simplicity
- Future-proofing
Need help choosing?
Get free personalised quotes from qualified suppliers in Belgium. Response within 24h, no obligation.